The following document was located in the Iredell County Public Library, Statesville, NC during August 1989 by Thomas L. Troutman of Pasadena, TX.
My father [?], Andrew Barringer, was for many years an Elder in St. Michael's Church, also a trustee of the land on which the church stood. Thieves had entered the church at various times and he believed the early records had been stolen.
After his death, a secretary and bookcase belonging to him was given to my mother, Lucinda, as a part of her dower. After her death the heirs of her estate, while examining the contents of this secretary, found a manuscript in which was written, as I recollect, "The First Communion, this Fourth Sunday in August, 1815." Then, just beneath this, "August 27, 1815." Then following was a list of names beginning with Charles N. Mills and wife, Elizabeth. This list contained twenty names, the last being, "Peter, a black man." The date of "The Second Communion," was given, but the names of the Communicants was blank. The date of the "Third Communion" was given followed by a list of perhaps thirty-five or forty names. These were followed by the lists of the "Fourth," "Fifth," "Sixth," and later Communions, the dates usually being at or near Easter or Christmas.
The fifth or sixth Communion was followed by the words, "at St. Michael's." The deed was given by Michael Walcher in September, 1823 to the trustees, Charles Mills, Martin Harkey, William Lippard, Jacob Troutman, and John Harkey, has in it the words, "on which the church now stands." From these records, and their circumstances, it is evident that this "First Communion" was the first communion of St. Michael's congregation, just 99 years, ten months ago. The pastor's name was not given, but from other sources, we learn that it was Robert Johnson Miller.
This manuscript was in the residence of P.A. Barringer, when it was burned on March 10, 1907, Statesville, NC.
June 26, 1915 Ada Fayette Barringer
Samuel Walcher Elizabeth Snider
Abner Mills Sarah Albertson
Joseph Clodfelter Simon Brown
John Barringer John Overcast
Abraham Richey Michael Overcast
Jacob Richey Benjamin Eller
Wm. Goodman Samuel Upright
Wm. McNeely Elizabeth King
Henry Troutman Charles Barringer
C. Clodfelter
Jane Randles
John F. Cook Catherine Barringer
Thos. M. Cook Betsy Cook
Absolam L. Harkey Margaret Harkey
Martin C. Harkey Elizabeth L. Plott
Wm. Harkey
John Snider
John W. Ostwald John Thomas, Sr.
Peter Ostwald John Thomas, Jr.
John Richey
Females
Sally Barringer Lucinda Plott
Catherine Bustle Sally Randles
Elizabeth S. Bustle Amy Ritchie
Margaret J. Bustle Elizabeth Ritchie
Mary M. Bustle Margaret Ritchie
Margaret Cook Sally Ritchie
Sarah Cook Sarah Scott
Rachel Hill Elizabeth Snider
Sarah Johnson Sophia Snider
Elizabeth Ostwald Mary C. Steel
Mary Ostwald
Peter F. Cook Jacob Richey
William McNeely Phillip Sowers
Abner Mills Anderson Thomas
James Overcast John Troutman
Michael Overcast Samuel Upright
Wm. Overcast
Mary C. Brown Martha Ann Richey
Margaret Clodfelter Jane Thomas
Martha Fennel Elizabeth Troutman
James Miles Catherine C. Plotts
Lucinda Miles Margaret Reamer
Jane M. Hosliver Susanna Overcast
David W. Lipe Charity S. Plott
Reinia C. Lipe Barbara Plyler
Sarah C. Miles Nancy M. Steel
Francis Ostwalt
David Kiestler Jacob W. Waggoner
Mary M. Kiestler Mary B. Waggoner
Mary M. King Peter F. Waggoner
Elizabeth Clodfelter Leah L. McNeely
George R. Clodfelter Henry M. Troutman
Henry I. Clodfelter Michael L. Walcher
Mary Dearman
John Lippard 2 Henry Ostwalt 1
Michael Overcast 4 Peter Ostwalt 1
John F. Cook 4 Joseph Clodfelter 2
Smith Randles 1 Sarah Johnson 1
Benjamin Eller 2 C. Clodfelter 2
Thos. M. Cook 2 Henry Troutman 2
Wm. Goodman 2 Abraham Richey 4
Henry Bustle 5 Martin S. Lenard 2
Daniel Walcher 2 Margaret Bustle 1
John Richey 2 Jacob Thomas 2
Elias Plott 3 Francis Ostwalt 3
John Thomas 7 Sarah Albertson 1
Simeon Brown 1 Elizabeth Brown 1
Sophia Snider 1 Jane Randles 1
Solomon Lence 3 Samuel Upright 2
John Lippard 2 John Richey 2
John F. Cook, Sr. 2 Sarah Albertson 1
John F. Cook, Jr. 1 Daniel Walcher 2
Michael Overcast 3 Abraham Richey 2
Anne Hoover 1 Phillip Sowers 2
Wm. Overcast 2 Phillip Clodfelter 2
Henry Bustle 6 Martin S. Lennard 2
Margaret Lence 1 Elizabeth Brown 1
Margaret Bustle 1 Jacob Thomas 2
Jane Randles 1 Wm. Lippard 4
John Overcast 1 Andrus Rickard 2
Abner Mills 2 Henry Troutman 2
Andrew Barringer 2 John Holshouser 2
John Barringer 1 Charles Barringer 1
Elias Plott 1 John Goodman 1
Catherine Brown 1 Pilliam Goodman 2
Sophia Blackwelder 1 John ----
Rachel Blackwelder 1 Christ'r Blackwelder 5
Francis Ostwalt William Goodman
Phillip Sowers George Boger
John Goodman, Sr. Peter F. Cook
Jacob Thomas Abner Deats
Thos. M. Cook John Richey
Abner Mills Henry Plyler
Michael Overcast John Arthurs
William Overcast Jacob Wooliever
Andrew Barringer John Holshouser
Hugh Plyler Martin S. Lennard
John Barringer John Thomas, Sr.--
Samuel Upright Died 03 April 1845
Christian Clodfelter Robert Slavin
Joseph Clodfelter Mathias Deats
James Overcast 13 October 1844
Burrel Plyler Tobias Goodman
Henry Troutman William Mills
Abraham Richey William Randles
Henry Bustle Solomon Lentz
Peter Ostwalt Jacob Troutman, Jr.
Elizabeth Sowers Died 04 March 1842
Ellon S. Thomas Rachel Lentz
Margaret Sowers Sophia Boger
Reliena Cook Mary Barringer, Sr.
Sarah Mills Mary Barringer
Margaret Overcast Barbara Barringer
Malinda Overcast Barbara Ostwalt
Lousinda Barringer Margaret Cook
Catherine Plyler Anne Richey
Catherine Upright Rachel Hill
Elizabeth Clodfelter Jane Rannels
Mary Clodfelter Leah Arthurs
Mary C. Slavin Elizabeth Snider
Sophia Blackwelder Sophia Snider
Rachel Blackwelder Mary Wooliever
Elizabeth Plyler Mary Holshouser
Sarah Albertson Margaret Lennard
Sarah Scott Elizabeth King
Elizabeth Troutman Barbara Thomas, Sr.
Esther Q. Troutman Fanney Thomas
Mary Richey Barbara Thomas, Jr.
Margaret Bustle Jane Thomas
Mary A. Bustle Eliz. S. Brown-Died 1842
Anne C. Bustle Sarah Cook
Margaret I. Bustle Ellen Goodman
Mary Barringer Sarah Ann Mills
Wm. Goodman 2 Jacob Thomas 2
Wm. Overcast 2 Andrew Barringer 2
C. Clodfelter 2 Henry Troutman 4
Henry Bustle 5 Joseph Clodfelter 2
Sarah Mills 1 Elizabeth King 1
Solomon Lentz 2 Elizabeth Snider 1
James Overcast 2 Sohpia Snider 1
Daniel Walcher 2 Nancy Steel 1
Christian Barringer 4 Sarah Scott 1
George Boger 2 Jane Rannels 1
Hugh Pliler 2 Sarah Johnson 1
John Holshouser 2 Sophia Blackwelder 1
John Lippard 4 Rachel Blackwelder 1
George Sanders 2 Leah Blackwelder 1
Peter Ostwalt 1 Sarah Albertson 1
Moses Richey 1
Andrew Barringer 2 William Overcash 1
C. Barringer 4 John Holshouser 2
Sollomon Lentz 2 Martin Lennard 1
Joseph Clodfelter 3 George Boger 2
Francis Ostwalt 5 Jacob Thomas 2
Henry Ostwalt 2 Jane Randels 1
John Lippard 4 Sarah Scott 1
John Thomas 5 Leah Blackwelder 1
Daniel Walcher 3 Rachel Blackwelder 1
Joseph Cook 2 Sarah Blackwelder 1
Henry Troutman 4 Susannah Plott 1
Thomas Cook 2 Christian Clodfelter 2
Margaret I.[?] Arthurs Wm. H. Lippard
Lawson A. Benfield Ellen R. Steel
Wm. Bostwell Robert Love Troutman
Fielden Kiles Elizabeth C. Upright
Paul Hartline Mary M. Upright
John W. Arthurs Harriet L. Onesby
Caleb A. Blackwelder Alfred Saunders
Sarah B. Bustle Sophia L. Saunders
Daniel Clodfelter Easter Scroggs
John I. Clodfelter Albert I. Thomas
Martha Ann Goodman James P. Thomas
John Q. Holshouser Jacob D. Troutman
John I. Troutman
Sarah Bean William Piler
Miles G. Christy Rufus W. Pirkman
Sarah Christy Barbara Rimmer
James Cook John Randles
James Deats Lusinda Randles
Harvey Fleming Michael Rimmer
Eliza Houston Elizabeth E Troutman
John Minser Margaret A. Troutman
Jacob Menser Wm. C. Sowers
Resolved that unless David Lipe present himself before the church council on the 4th Sabbath of May and answer in behalf of himself or otherwise under satisfaction to some of the Council privately, he be suspended or Expelled as the case may require by the order of the Church Council.
April 23rd 1843 [Signed] Henry Troutman